Key takeaways
- Otterly.AI is the cheapest way in ($29/mo) and works well as a monitoring tool for a small marketing team, but every paid plan caps you at 3 of 7 engines and it has no content publishing or visitor attribution.
- Semrush's AI visibility features make sense mainly if you already live in Semrush. Pricing has shifted: older sources cite a $99/mo add-on, while Semrush's current pricing page bundles AI search into plans from $199/mo.
- Promptwatch costs more per month than Otterly's entry plan, but it covers the full loop: tracking, crawler logs, content gaps, content creation, publishing, and traffic measurement.
- Prompt counts are not comparable across vendors. Compare cost per tracked response, engine access, and what happens after you find a gap.
- Check every price on the vendor's own page before you buy. Several comparison articles online (including vendor-written ones) are out of date.
Why this comparison is harder than it looks
These three tools are not the same kind of product. That is the first thing to get straight.
Otterly.AI is a focused AI search monitor. Semrush is a broad SEO and marketing suite that added AI visibility reporting. Promptwatch is an AI visibility and GEO platform that tries to cover monitoring, diagnosis, content, and measurement in one product.
A marketing team usually does not need "the best tracker." It needs to know whether it is mentioned in ChatGPT, why or why not, and what to publish next. So I will judge each tool on that chain, not on dashboard polish.
A word on sources. Much of what you will find online about these tools is written by the vendors themselves. Otterly's "25 best AI SEO tools" list ranks Otterly second. Promptwatch's "best GEO tools" list ranks Promptwatch first. I work from the vendors' own pricing pages where I can, and I flag where figures conflict.

Quick comparison
| Otterly.AI | Semrush AI visibility | Promptwatch | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $29/mo | $199/mo (SEO + AI Search Starter) | $95/mo |
| Entry volume | 20 prompts | 50 prompts, 1 domain | 50 prompts, 6,000 responses |
| Mid plan | Standard $189/mo, 160 prompts | Pro+ $299/mo (15 websites) | Professional $245/mo, 150 prompts |
| Engine access | 3 of 7 engines on each paid tier | ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and more | All supported models on every plan |
| AI crawler logs | Agent analytics from Standard | No | From Professional |
| Content creation | Audits and recommendations | Separate add-ons | Content Agent from Business, AEO articles from Professional |
| AI visitor tracking | Limited | Separate add-on | On every plan |
| Best for | Solo marketers, small teams on a budget | Teams already on Semrush | Teams that want to fix gaps, not just see them |
Prices are pulled from the vendors' pricing pages and third-party comparisons, and they change. Confirm at promptwatch.com/pricing, otterly.ai/pricing, and semrush.com/pricing.
Otterly.AI: the budget monitor
Otterly.AI was founded in Vienna in 2024 by the team that previously sold Usersnap. It tracks brand mentions and citations across engines like ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, and Claude.
Otterly.AI

What it costs now
Otterly moved to a credit-based model, and its current pricing differs from what older roundups say. Per Otterly's pricing page:
- Lite: $29/mo, 20 prompts, 1 workspace, daily tracking
- Standard: $189/mo, 160 prompts, unlimited workspaces, unlimited recommendations, API and MCP access
- Premium: $489/mo, 535 prompts
- Enterprise: custom, from 1,000 prompts
The catch is engine access. Every paid tier lists "3 of 7 AI engines," and only Enterprise unlocks all of them. That contradicts the older claim that all six engines come with every plan. If your buyers use Gemini and Claude as much as ChatGPT, price that in. Third-party comparisons also note Claude and Gemini as paid add-ons.
Where it fits
Otterly is a good first tool. Setup is quick, the price is honest, and the free GEO audit and fan-out tools are useful even if you never subscribe. For a solo marketer who needs a weekly view of mentions and cited sources, it does the job.
It is thinner after that. There is no native content publishing workflow, and no visitor analytics tying AI answers to conversions. One Reddit reviewer in r/DigitalMarketing rated it 2/5, praising the source and social-mention tracking but finding implementation hard. That is one opinion, not a verdict, but it matches the pattern: strong at watching, lighter at acting.
At Standard, the cost works out to roughly $1.18 per prompt ($189 for 160 prompts). That is the best per-prompt price of the three, as long as 3 engines are enough for you.
Semrush AI visibility: convenience for existing customers
Semrush added AI visibility to its suite in 2025. The pricing story is murky, so be careful here.
The pricing confusion
Several sources describe a $99/mo AI Toolkit add-on with 25 prompts, one domain, and one user, with extra prompts at $60 per 50 and extra domains at $99 each. One of those sources also says Claude is locked behind an Enterprise tier. But Semrush's current pricing page now sells "SEO & AI Search" plans under Semrush One:
- SEO: $139/mo
- Starter (SEO + AI Search): $199/mo, tracking 50 prompts daily on 1 domain
- Pro+: $299/mo, 15 websites
I could not verify whether a standalone add-on still exists, because the pricing page scrape was truncated. Treat the $99 figure as possibly out of date and ask a Semrush rep.
Semrush also documents its data approach: a prompt and response dataset sourced partly from AI search clickstream data, refreshed weekly. That is a different method from scraping each engine's live interface for your specific prompts, so expect it to behave differently. Worth asking about before you rely on it for brand-level decisions.
Where it fits
If your team already pays for Semrush and uses keyword, backlink, and audit tools every week, having AI visibility in the same login is a real convenience. You see traditional rankings and AI mentions side by side.
If you only want AI visibility, you are paying for a suite you will not open. Comparison pieces consistently call the AI module secondary to the legacy tools, and the Promptwatch-authored comparison notes no AI crawler logs and separate add-ons for content and conversion features. Semrush also owns Otterly's help docs now, according to one comparison, though both products are still sold separately as far as I can tell. Verify before assuming any bundling.
Promptwatch: tracking plus the fix
Promptwatch is the one built around closing the loop. It monitors the real interfaces of ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Meta AI, and others across countries and languages, then traces where answers come from, helps you act, and measures whether the action worked.

The loop in practice
- Monitor: prompts, Visibility Score, sentiment, share of voice, and the individual claims AI makes about you (Brand Narrative).
- Trace: which of your pages get cited, which Reddit threads and YouTube videos AI uses, and where your brand is named on third-party pages.
- Act: content gap analysis, an Action Board of prioritized tasks, and the Content Agent, which writes and publishes to WordPress, Webflow, or Framer.
- Measure: IP-verified AI crawler logs, page tracking, and visitor analytics that show whether a page was crawled, cited, and clicked.
What it costs
| Plan | Price | Projects | Prompts | Responses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Essential | $95/mo | 1 | 50 | 6,000 |
| Professional | $245/mo | 2 | 150 | 18,000 |
| Business | $579/mo | 5 | 350 | 42,000 |
Every plan includes unlimited team seats, all supported AI models, Agent Chat, Brand Narrative, content gap analysis, visitor analytics, site audits, and MCP and API access. Professional adds AI crawler logs and AEO articles. Business adds the automated Content Agent, state and city tracking, Fact Check, Shopping insights, and Ads Radar. There is a 7-day free trial on monthly billing, and annual billing gives 12 months for the price of 10.
At Professional, the cost is about $1.63 per prompt, a bit above Otterly's Standard. But the prompt number is only half the story. A prompt tracked on every engine, plus crawler logs and a content workflow, is a different purchase from a prompt on three engines with a dashboard.
Honest limits
The jump from $245 to $579 is steep, and the content automation sits at Business. Agency plans exclude the Content Agent and AEO articles. Otterly's own competitor page argues that Promptwatch's workspace limits hurt agencies on its mid plans. That is fair for agencies comparing against Otterly's unlimited workspaces, though Promptwatch's agency plans (Kick-off $199, Growth $399, Scale $799) include unlimited projects. A marketing team running one brand will not hit that limit.
For more on how each side stacks up, see the Promptwatch vs Otterly and Promptwatch vs Semrush pages. Both are written by Promptwatch, so read them with that in mind.
Why prompt counts mislead
The three vendors cap usage in three different ways:
- Otterly caps by prompts and monthly credits
- Promptwatch caps by prompts and responses
- Semrush caps by prompts per domain
So "50 prompts" on one tool is not "50 prompts" on another. Ask three questions: how many engines does each prompt run on, how often, and what do extra prompts cost?
Also keep in mind how AI answers behave. Promptwatch's average sources per response data shows ChatGPT citing about 5 sources per web-search answer, while Google AI Overviews and Perplexity cite about 10. Copilot swung from under 2 to nearly 17 sources within a few weeks. Two practical consequences: with only around 5 citation slots in ChatGPT, you need to see which prompts you win and lose, not just a blended score. And Copilot results should be judged on monthly trends, not weekly snapshots.
Responses are also non-deterministic. The same prompt can return different answers run to run, so single data points mean little. Whatever tool you choose, look at trends over repeated runs.
Which one fits which marketing team
| Your situation | Best fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Solo marketer, first AI visibility project, tight budget | Otterly.AI | $29 entry, fast setup, free audit tools |
| Team already paying for Semrush, wants one login | Semrush | Side-by-side SEO and AI data, no new vendor |
| Team that needs to find gaps and publish fixes | Promptwatch | Gap analysis, Content Agent, CMS publishing, measurement |
| Team that needs to prove AI traffic and conversions | Promptwatch | Visitor analytics and crawler logs tied to citations |
| Team that cares about Claude and Gemini coverage | Promptwatch | All supported models on every plan |
| Agency with many small clients | Otterly.AI or Promptwatch agency plans | Unlimited workspaces vs unlimited projects |
A simple way to decide
Ask what you will do on Monday after the first report arrives.
If the answer is "watch it and report it up," Otterly is enough and cheaper. If the answer is "keep using Semrush for everything," stay in Semrush and accept shallower AI data. If the answer is "figure out why we are not cited and publish pages that fix it," you want a platform that does the second half of the job.
That last case is where Promptwatch earns its higher price. Case studies back the pattern: Crisp reported 2x higher conversion rates from AI traffic and scaled content to 5-10 articles a day, as described in the Crisp case study. Those are Promptwatch's own published results, so weigh accordingly.
Questions to ask before you buy
- Does the tool collect answers from each engine's real interface or from an API? User-facing answers and citations can differ from API output.
- Which engines are included at my plan, and which are add-ons?
- Can I see AI crawler activity on my site, or only AI answers?
- Does it tell me what to publish, and can it publish for me?
- How do I connect AI mentions to traffic and conversions?
- What does my bill look like when I double my prompts?
The best way to test is to run the same 20 to 30 prompts through each tool's trial. Otterly offers a 7 to 14-day trial depending on the page you read, Promptwatch offers a 7-day trial on monthly billing, and Semrush has no trial for its AI toolkit according to one source. Compare what each shows for the same prompts, then look at whether it tells you what to do.
If you want to browse beyond these three, the directory at bestgeosoftware.com lists other GEO platforms, and Promptwatch's free AI visibility report gives a no-login baseline before you commit to anything.
Verdict
Otterly.AI is the right pick when budget is the main constraint and monitoring is the goal. Semrush is the right pick when you are already a customer and convenience beats depth. Promptwatch is the right pick when the goal is more AI-driven traffic, not a prettier visibility chart.
Most marketing teams outgrow pure monitoring within a quarter or two. If you expect to, start with the tool that already does the work after the report.
