Key takeaways
- AthenaHQ's strength is revenue attribution through Shopify and GA4. Its pricing page doesn't list server-side crawler logs, which is the gap most teams hit first.
- Crawler logs answer a question that comes before any visibility work: can AI bots even read your pages? Traffic attribution answers the one after: did the citation send anyone?
- Promptwatch is the most complete option here, with IP-verified crawler logs, visitor analytics and content publishing in one product, from $95/mo with a 7-day trial.
- Scrunch AI and Profound also go deep on agent traffic. Siteline AI, Bear AI and Scriptbee are narrower tools built around crawler and agent analytics.
- Pricing in competitor roundups changes fast. Confirm every number on the vendor's own page before you buy.
Why crawler logs and attribution matter more than another visibility score
Most AI visibility tools run a set of prompts, check whether your brand shows up, and give you a score. That's useful. It's also where the story stops for a lot of teams.
Two things are missing from that picture. The first is whether AI crawlers can actually fetch your pages. If GPTBot gets a 403 from your WAF, no amount of content work will fix your visibility. The second is whether any of this visibility turns into visits and conversions. A brand can be mentioned in 40% of answers and still send zero traffic.
That's why the shortlist below is built around two capabilities:
- Server-side crawler logs (which AI bots visit, which pages they read, where they fail).
- AI traffic attribution (visits and conversions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and others).
If you want a broader view of the category first, the GEO software directory at bestgeosoftware.com lists most of the tools mentioned here.
Where AthenaHQ stands
AthenaHQ is a capable platform. Starter tracks 11 AI models, connects to Shopify, GA4 and a list of CMSs, and holds a 4.9/5 rating on G2 according to ContentMonk's comparison. Its edge is joining AI visibility to revenue, particularly for e-commerce and mid-market teams.
The reasons people look elsewhere come up repeatedly in the comparison posts I read:
- The paid floor is $295/mo ($245 or so billed annually), after a free Essential plan that comes with a one-time grant of about 300 credits.
- Credits are the unit of measure. One credit buys one AI response, so 3,600 monthly credits cover roughly 30 prompts across 4 engines daily, or about 11 prompts a day across all 11 engines.
- Agent analytics isn't listed on the pricing page, and the most advanced features (the Citation Engine, Knowledge Base, SSO, multi-region tracking) sit on Enterprise.
Note that most of these numbers come from competitor-authored blog posts. Treat them as a starting point and check AthenaHQ's pricing page yourself.
What good crawler logs look like
Not every "AI crawler monitoring" feature is the same thing. Some tools infer crawler activity from a snippet or a user-agent string. Better ones read raw server or CDN logs and verify the request source.
What I'd look for:
- IP verification against each operator's published ranges, so spoofed user agents don't inflate your numbers.
- Per-crawler breakdown, not just "OpenAI". Training crawlers (GPTBot) and answer-time fetchers (ChatGPT-User, OAI-SearchBot) tell you very different things.
- Error reporting in plain language, so you know whether a page failed because of robots.txt, a WAF rule or a timeout.
- A link between crawls and citations, so you can tell an access problem from a content problem.
- Setup through your CDN or host (Cloudflare, Fastly, Vercel, CloudFront) rather than a heavy install.
The per-crawler point matters. Promptwatch Data's AI crawler traffic report (June 8 to September 6, 2026) found OpenAI at 79.8% of verified AI crawler requests in the week of August 31 to September 6, down from 94.8% in the week of June 8. Provider totals hide the split between training crawlers and answer-time fetchers, which is why the report recommends the per-crawler view.
Another data point worth knowing: in Promptwatch's Meta-WebIndexer report, that single user agent went from about 2.2% of tracked AI crawler requests in mid-July 2026 to 37.8% on August 9. The report links this to unconfirmed claims that Meta is building its own search index, so treat the cause as alleged. The practical lesson is that new bots show up fast, and you only notice if you're reading your own logs.
A useful sanity check from that same report: if a provider has a big share in the benchmark but sits near zero in your logs, you are probably blocked or unreachable for it. Check robots.txt, CDN and WAF rules first.
What good AI traffic attribution looks like
Attribution in AI search is messier than in classic analytics. Referrers are inconsistent, and ChatGPT stopped sending a referrer on October 8, 2026. Tools that rely on referrer headers alone will undercount.
Things to check:
- Which AI sources are recognized (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, DeepSeek and others).
- Whether it handles utm-tagged ChatGPT visits, now that the referrer is gone.
- Conversions, not just sessions. Crisp reported that AI traffic converts at 2x other channels, and you only see that if conversions are attached.
- Page-level data, so you can see which cited pages actually earn visits.
- Whether it sits next to GA4 or replaces it. For e-commerce, Shopify revenue attribution (AthenaHQ's strength) is hard to beat.
If you're setting up the measurement side yourself, Promptwatch's Academy has a practical guide on attributing AI traffic. And a simple baseline in Google Analytics is to filter for AI assistant referrers and watch whether that segment grows month over month.
Comparison table
| Tool | Crawler logs | AI traffic attribution | Content publishing | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Promptwatch | IP-verified, per-crawler, with crawl-to-citation view | Visitor analytics with conversions | Content Agent publishes to WordPress, Webflow, Framer | $95/mo |
| AthenaHQ | Not listed on pricing page | Shopify and GA4 revenue attribution | Recommendations, limited execution | $295/mo (credit-based) |
| Scrunch AI | Agent traffic feed with visit frequency by page | Treats agent traffic as its own channel | Limited | About $250/mo |
| Profound | AI crawler traffic and attribution across domains | Yes | Limited | Varies by plan |
| Otterly.ai | Agent Analytics on Standard plans and up (per Ranketta) | Limited | No | About $29/mo |
| Omnia | Not a focus | GA4 AI SEO traffic channel integration | Limited | Check vendor |
Prices come from the vendor and roundup pages cited in the research and may have changed.
The alternatives
1. Promptwatch
This is the one I'd start with for the specific combination you asked about. Promptwatch tracks prompts and citations, but underneath that it reads server-side logs of AI crawlers hitting your site: which bots, which pages, how often, and what errors they hit. Visits are verified against each operator's published IP ranges, so spoofed bots are filtered out.

The useful part is the crawl-to-citation path. Each page shows whether bots read it, whether AI cited it, and whether anyone then visited. That lets you separate an access problem from a content problem, which is the thing a visibility score alone can't do. Visitor analytics then tracks AI-referred traffic and conversions from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, DeepSeek and more, and an optional setting counts visits tagged utm_source=chatgpt.com as ChatGPT traffic.
Setup is through Cloudflare, AWS CloudFront, Fastly, Vercel, Netlify, Akamai, Google Cloud CDN, a custom endpoint, or the official WordPress plugin (which also captures AI-referred visitors). More detail on the feature is on the AI crawler logs page.
Then it does something AthenaHQ-style tools mostly leave to you: the Action Board prioritizes fixes, and on Business the Content Agent writes and publishes pages to WordPress, Webflow or Framer, then tracks whether each one gets crawled, cited and clicked. TreeHouse (Pararius) got AI search to roughly 25% of organic conversions by fixing crawler access and publishing proprietary data, according to its case study.
Pricing, confirmed against the Promptwatch pricing page at promptwatch.com/pricing:
- Essential $95/mo: 50 prompts, daily tracking, visitor analytics, site audits. No crawler logs on this tier.
- Professional $245/mo: 150 prompts, 25M crawler logs, 5 AEO articles, custom reports.
- Business $579/mo: 350 prompts, 100M crawler logs, Content Agent, state and city tracking, Fact Check, Shopping, Ads Radar.
- Agencies: Kick-off $199, Growth $399, Scale $799, all with crawler logs and unlimited projects.
One correction to some roundups: a few of them say crawler logs come on every plan or that only 4 models are tracked. Promptwatch's own pricing is the authority here. Crawler logs start at Professional, and every plan tracks all supported AI models. Where AthenaHQ keeps an edge is native Shopify revenue attribution.
There's a Promptwatch vs AthenaHQ comparison, a 7-day free trial on monthly billing, and a free AI visibility report if you want a look before paying.
2. Scrunch AI
Scrunch treats agent traffic as its own channel. Its crawler feed logs when AI bots visit your pages, how frequently, and which pages they return to. It's a good fit for enterprise brands that want to manage a separate experience for AI agents.

The trade-offs: pricing starts around $250/mo, with 4 engines on Core and 9 on Enterprise, and it doesn't have Reddit tracking or the publishing loop. See the Promptwatch vs Scrunch page for a side-by-side.
3. Profound
Profound is the enterprise pick. It tracks AI crawler traffic and attribution across unlimited domains and has deep prompt demand data. It costs more and is built for larger teams.
Profound

If you're comparing it against Promptwatch directly, there's a Promptwatch vs Profound breakdown.
4. Otterly.ai
Otterly is the budget option, from roughly $29/mo. According to Ranketta's roundup, its Agent Analytics reads your server logs and is available on Standard plans and up. It's a monitor, though. There's no content generation and attribution is lighter.
Otterly.AI

5. Omnia
Omnia's relevant feature is a GA4 AI SEO traffic channel integration that connects AI visibility to organic traffic and revenue attribution. It's more of an AthenaHQ-style answer than a crawler-log one.
6. Narrower crawler and agent analytics tools
If you only need the log side, a few smaller tools in the catalog focus on it: Siteline AI (agent traffic analytics), Bear AI (turning agent traffic into revenue), and Scriptbee (AI crawler monitoring across unlimited domains).

These won't replace a visibility platform. They're worth a look if your question is purely "who is crawling us?" For more tools in this vein, the directory at agenticseotools.com is a good place to browse.
How to choose
| If you need... | Pick |
|---|---|
| Crawler logs, attribution and content that publishes, in one product | Promptwatch |
| Shopify and GA4 revenue attribution for e-commerce | AthenaHQ (stay) or Omnia |
| Agent traffic managed as its own channel | Scrunch AI |
| Enterprise prompt demand data plus crawler attribution | Profound |
| The cheapest monitor with some log visibility | Otterly.ai |
| Only crawler or agent analytics | Siteline AI, Scriptbee |
A practical way to test any of these
Skip the demos and run a short test on your own site.
- Connect logs first. Setup through your CDN should take minutes. If it takes a sprint, that's a signal.
- Check for blocks. Look at GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot. Any near-zero provider is a robots.txt or WAF suspect. Promptwatch's free AI crawler URL inspector and Agentic Readiness Check are quick ways to confirm.
- Pick 5 pages that should be cited and see whether bots read them. If they don't, fix access before touching content.
- Turn on attribution and wait two to four weeks. Small numbers are normal. What matters is whether you can see page-level visits and conversions.
- Ask whether the tool tells you what to do next. A log with no action attached is a report, not a workflow.
Final thought
AthenaHQ is still a reasonable choice if Shopify revenue attribution is your main need. If your actual problem is "are AI engines reading our content, and is it sending anyone?", pick a tool where crawler logs and visitor analytics are first-class. Promptwatch covers both and closes the loop with publishing, which is why it sits at the top of this list. Verify current pricing on each vendor's page, since several of the figures above come from third-party roundups.



