Key takeaways
- Otterly.AI is still a fair starting point for agencies. The $29 Lite plan is cheap, but it tracks 3 of 7 engines and has no API, MCP or Data Studio connector. Those arrive at Standard ($189).
- Agencies usually leave for one of three reasons: deeper reporting and history, more engine coverage, or a tool that helps fix visibility problems instead of only reporting them.
- Peec AI is the most direct multi-client reporting rival. Promptwatch goes further into execution (content, crawler logs, traffic). SE Visible and Profound fit specific reporting styles.
- Before you switch, check whether the tool collects answers from real interfaces, how it isolates client workspaces, and whether pricing scales per client or per prompt.
- Confirm every price on the vendor's own page. Several third-party comparison tables I found were out of date.
Why agencies start looking beyond Otterly.AI
Otterly.AI earns its reputation. It holds 4.7 out of 5 across 54 G2 reviews, none below four stars, and reviewers keep saying the same thing: it sets up fast and the prompt-level dashboard is easy to read. If you are selling your first GEO retainer, that matters.

The friction shows up once you have five or ten clients on it. Reviewers ask for more customizable reporting and more granular historical trend data. Some see refresh lags when tracking several domains at once. Others want concrete recommendations rather than data they still have to interpret.
The pricing page adds a few details worth knowing before you plan around it:
- Lite ($29/mo) gives you 20 prompts, 3 of 7 engines, 1 workspace and no API, MCP or Data Studio connector.
- Standard ($189/mo) gives you 160 prompts, unlimited workspaces, the Data Studio connector, 2,000 API and 2,000 MCP requests a month.
- Premium ($489/mo) gives you 535 prompts and is pitched at mid-sized companies and agencies.
- Pricing is credit-based. I did not verify whether adding engines or tracking more often burns credits faster, so test that on a trial before quoting a client.
- Annual billing takes 15% off.
Otterly lists seven engines in total: ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, Microsoft Copilot, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Claude. But every plan from Lite to Premium covers only three of them. For an agency whose clients ask "what about Gemini?" in the first meeting, that is a real constraint.
Otterly also runs a dedicated agency program, with extra prompts, a partner directory listing, co-selling support and pitch report generation. Those are vendor claims I could not verify independently, but they are worth asking about on a demo call.

What agencies actually need from a prompt tracker
A tool can look good in a solo evaluation and still fall apart in an agency. Here is the checklist I would run through.
Real prompt tracking, not just API calls
Answers shown in the actual ChatGPT or AI Overviews interface can differ from what the API returns, including the citations. If your client opens ChatGPT and sees something different from your report, you lose the argument. Ask every vendor how it collects data.
There is a second wrinkle. The prompts you track are not the queries ChatGPT actually runs. Promptwatch Data's query fanout report shows ChatGPT averaging about 2.15 web searches per response in early December 2025 and about 1.84 by early March, with fanout queries getting shorter and more keyword-like over time. So a tracker that shows you fanouts is more useful for content planning than one that only shows the final answer.
Client isolation and seats
Each client should live in a separate workspace or project, with login or view-only access that shows only their brand. Unlimited team seats matter because account managers, strategists and clients all want in. Per-seat pricing punishes agencies.
Reporting that survives a client meeting
Look for scheduled PDFs, Looker Studio connectors, API or MCP access, and white-label options. Be honest about which of those a tool really has. I could not verify white-label or client-portal capabilities for most of the tools below, so treat that column as a question to ask, not an assumption.
Reporting that is honest about engine differences
Citation counts differ by engine. Promptwatch Data's average sources report shows ChatGPT citing about 5 sources per web-search answer, while Google AI Overviews and Perplexity sit near 10. Copilot swung from under 2 to nearly 17 sources within weeks before settling lower. If you chart those side by side without a footnote, clients will draw the wrong conclusions. Perplexity makes a stable benchmark because its count barely moves, and a Copilot swing is more likely a retrieval change on Microsoft's side than something your client did.
A path from data to action
The most common complaint about monitoring-only tools is that the report ends and the real work starts. Decide whether you want to do that work yourself, or whether you want the tool to help with it.
Otterly.AI alternatives at a glance
| Tool | Best for | Agency fit | Content creation | Starting price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Promptwatch | Agencies that want tracking plus execution | Dedicated agency plans, unlimited projects and seats | Yes (Enterprise for agencies) | $199/mo (Kick-off) |
| Peec AI | Multi-client reporting | Unlimited users, separate agency page | No | $95/mo |
| SE Visible | Account teams reporting to mid-market clients | Unlimited seats, Looker Studio, API, MCP | No | $99/mo |
| Profound | Enterprise-scale coverage and long history | Multi-company accounts | Profound Agents | $99/mo |
| AthenaHQ | Tying visibility to revenue data | Unlimited seats | Optimization agent | $295/mo |
| Scrunch AI | Sentiment and citation monitoring | 5 licenses on Core | Basic generation | $250/mo |
| Rankscale | Agency-focused tracking | Built for agencies | No | Check vendor |
Starting prices for the third-party tools come from comparison articles and may be stale. I verified Peec and Promptwatch against their own pricing pages, and Otterly against its live page.
Promptwatch: the option for agencies that want to fix, not only report
Promptwatch is where I would look first if your clients keep asking "okay, so what do we do about it?" Most tools in this category stop at a dashboard. Promptwatch tracks visibility from the real interfaces of ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Perplexity, Copilot, Meta AI and Alexa, then traces where the answers come from, then acts on the gaps, then measures whether the fix worked.

For agencies, the relevant bits are concrete:
- The agency plans have unlimited projects, unlimited prompts, unlimited team seats, all models, country, state and city tracking, Brand Narrative, Ads Radar, crawler logs, visitor analytics, site audit, custom reports, and MCP and API access.
- Kick-off is $199/mo (10,000 responses), Growth is $399/mo (25,000 responses) and Scale is $799/mo (65,000 responses, plus hourly tracking options, local GEO targeting, Fact Check and an audit log). Confirm on promptwatch.com/pricing. All three have a 7-day free trial on monthly billing.
- IP-verified AI crawler logs tell you whether a client's problem is access (bots can't read the page) or content (bots read it and still don't cite it). That is a diagnosis most monitoring tools cannot make.
- Visitor analytics measure the AI-referred traffic and conversions, so you can show revenue impact instead of only visibility scores.
- Agent Chat acts as an analyst over each client's data and can build dashboards and PDF reports on request. Scheduled PDFs can go to client inboxes.
- Pitch projects can be created through the API and MCP, which helps when you're winning new business.
Two honest caveats. Agency plans do not include the Content Agent, the Knowledge Base, 360 Insights or ChatGPT Shopping. Agencies that want content generation, a white-label dashboard and client portal, or SSO need Enterprise. And Otterly's comparison page claims Promptwatch has "no dedicated agency program". The pricing page shows a separate Agencies toggle with its own plans, so that claim does not hold up, though Otterly's partner-directory and co-selling perks are a different thing.
On the results side, Monks uses the Answer Gap Report and Visibility Score to build content roadmaps for enterprise clients. There is also a GEO for agencies guide in the Academy and a head-to-head Promptwatch vs Otterly page. If you want to see a client brand before committing, the free AI visibility report needs no login. More detail on the agency setup is at promptwatch.com/solutions/agencies.
Peec AI: the closest match for multi-client reporting
Peec is the one most comparison articles put first for agencies, and the reasoning is sound. Every plan includes unlimited users, competitors and languages, with daily tracking.
From its pricing page: Starter is $95/mo (50 prompts, 1 project, 1 country), Pro is $245/mo (150 prompts, 2 projects, 3 countries), Advanced is $495/mo (350 prompts, 5 projects, Looker Studio), and Enterprise is custom with unlimited projects, API access and SSO. Self-serve plans list ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overview, AI Mode, Gemini and a few regional engines, but no Claude or Copilot in that list. There is also a separate agency pricing page that I did not scrape, so check it directly.
One comparison I read described Peec making each client an isolated project that opens by login or link, with view-only links showing chosen charts and a weekly MCP task that posts a per-client summary to Slack. That is a useful setup for clients who read numbers before meetings. Otterly beats it on GEO URL audits, which one comparison says run on every Otterly plan.
Watch the project count. Peec's tiers cap projects at 1, 2 and 5, so a larger roster pushes you toward Enterprise or the agency page quickly.
SE Visible: stored answers for the client readout
SE Visible, from SE Ranking, collects answers in a real browser session, daily by default, and ties each answer to its cited sources and named rivals across ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Mode and AI Overviews. Seats are unlimited, and reporting can run through Looker Studio, API or MCP.

The trade-offs: no white label yet, AI visibility only, and Claude and Copilot support are listed as planned. If your readouts are the thing clients value most, the ability to open a stored answer when someone asks "which day was this?" is a real selling point. If you already live in SE Ranking for classic SEO, the fit is natural.

Profound: long history for enterprise clients
Profound is the enterprise name in this space. Comparison articles credit it with "All time" history on both agency tiers, so no client workspace loses its early record, and with 100 daily-tracked prompts per workspace plus CSV and JSON exports. Starter reportedly gives you one seat, so agency work happens on the higher tiers. Its Promptwatch comparison is more favorable to Promptwatch on price, Reddit tracking, ChatGPT Shopping and execution, but Profound is a strong monitoring product for large accounts.
Profound

See the Promptwatch vs Profound page for a detailed side-by-side.
Other options worth a look
AthenaHQ ties AI visibility to revenue data and has unlimited seats, but starts higher at $295/mo.
Scrunch AI is a solid pick for sentiment and citation monitoring, though the entry price sits at $250/mo.
Rankscale is positioned directly at agencies. I did not verify its pricing or refresh cadence, so treat it as a shortlist item rather than a recommendation.

Rankability and Decoding both appear in agency-focused roundups for white-label reporting, but I could not verify what they include, so ask for a demo.

Keyword.com adds a white-label add-on that moves reporting to your own domain with password protection, but its credits scale with refresh frequency. Otterly is more predictable because daily tracking comes with every plan.
For a wider list, the AI rank tracking tools directory and the GEO software directory cover many more options.
How to choose
If you mostly sell monitoring and monthly reports
Peec AI or SE Visible. Both are straightforward, unlimited-seat tools. Choose Peec if clients want self-serve access, SE Visible if your team wants stored answers for readouts.
If you sell outcomes
Promptwatch. When the deliverable is published pages, fixed crawl errors and measured AI traffic, you need the content gap analysis, crawler logs and visitor analytics in one place. One comparison I read made the same point about managed programs: agencies that own delivery prefer tools where the output is published work with tracked outcomes, not a monthly PDF.
If you have fewer than three clients and a tight budget
Stay on Otterly. Its Lite plan covers four default engines in one workspace for $29, and the Standard plan unlocks unlimited workspaces and Data Studio. You do not need to pay for multi-client reporting before you have multiple clients.
If you already pay for Semrush or Ahrefs
Their AI modules are fine for monthly share-of-voice reporting on under 100 prompts. Semrush and Ahrefs are traditional suites bolting on AI tracking, so expect fixed prompt sets and no crawler logs.
A short migration checklist
- Export your prompt lists and tags from Otterly before canceling.
- Pick two clients and run both tools side by side for two weeks.
- Compare the same prompts on the same day and note where the answers differ.
- Test the client-facing output: share a view-only link, send a scheduled PDF, open the Looker Studio connector.
- Check what happens to history. Starting a fresh baseline means your month-over-month charts reset.
- Price it at your real prompt volume, with credits or responses counted the vendor's way.
If you also need help with the strategy side of AI search, an agency like 1001 SEO Media covers GEO alongside technical SEO and content, and it uses Promptwatch as its AI visibility platform.
Bottom line
Otterly.AI is a good first tool and a mediocre fifth-client tool. If you want closer multi-client reporting, Peec AI is the natural step. If you want to move from reporting into execution, Promptwatch's agency plans start at $199/mo with unlimited projects and seats, and the free trial lets you test it on a real client before you commit. Verify every price on the vendor's pricing page, because this category changes monthly.



